So, the designers of the .30 Carbine pretty clearly accomplished their goal of building a cartridge neatly filling gap in between typical rifle … .45 ACP ('08).45 ACP ('15).45 Colt.45 Super.460 Rowland.223 Rifle Acknowledgements. However, in all fairness, the M1 Carbine was not designed for that sort of use in the first place. carbine, instead of using the .45 ACP? This model works within the framework of California legalities, and still looks good, functions well and offers a substantially similar performance basis. While the .30 Carbine is hopelessly outclassed by most rifle rounds, it is more powerful than many pistol rounds that are also popular deer hunting cartridges, such as the .357 Magnum, 10mm Auto, and .45 Colt. The .30 carbine does make a nice home defense weapon though. The use of this gun as a law enforcement and military firearm made it a historical figure and it has been in production with Thompson/Auto Ordnance ever since. No less an authority than Jim Cirillo of the New York Police Department’s Stakeout Squad (who was in over a dozen shootouts) hailed the .30 Carbine as one of the most effective man stopping cartridges available (when using hollow points). The M1 Carbine was developed as a compromise to give them a weapon that was lighter and easier to carry than a full sized rifle, but more powerful and with a longer effective range than a pistol or submachine gun. Finding the best .45 ACP Carbine used to be limited to only a couple options, and ultimately consumers felt like they were dealt a specific play in the platform. As for the .45 Automatic pistol vs carbine ballistic test can be found here […] It also has comparable energy and velocity from the muzzle to 50 yards to .44 Remington magnum. This is the perfect Sonoran Desert rifle.
Those looking for a proven design that don’t mind the heavy weight of the model. Very few other shooters will have something as worthy of looks, touches and questions. The reliability of the component parts is exceptional, and the price point is realistic. The Magpul furniture makes it a very comfortable, easily implementable carbine and the use of a Glock Magazine makes it easy to find extra mags for.
Risk Management. This email contact address is not an "Ask the Firearms Expert" service. As for the .45 Automatic pistol vs carbine ballistic test can be found here […].380 Auto pistol vs carbine - Range Hot - March 4, 2016 […] If you are curious how the .380 carbine stacks up against the 9mm Luger carbine, follow this link to see that ballistic test. Though not a great choice for concealed carry, the .30 Carbine can still be a good choice for home defense when concealment is not nearly as big of an issue. The simple, ambidextrous styling and the easy maintenance and gun breakdown make this an easy to care for option, despite the sometimes awkward polymer shell. The poor terminal performance of .30 Carbine FMJ bullets (especially compared to the .30-06) has been well documented. Location: Mill Creek (Just north east of Seattle). I love my M1 carbine, its home is right by my bed.
Personally I have no problem with a 44 magnum pistol on deer out to 100 yards. Also, check to see if there are magazine restrictions for hunting in your state if you are hunting with an M1 Carbine.
Cookies help us deliver our Services. Over 6 million M1 Carbines were produced (by a wide range of companies like the Inland Division of General Motors, International Business Machines (IBM), the Underwood Typewriter Company, and the Rock-Ola Jukebox Company), and they are by far the most popular firearm chambered in .30 Carbine. What practical real world benefit would the 30 Carbine round offer that would offset the nightmare of getting yet another item to troops in all theaters of the war? The parts and accessories included in this package means you are getting the complete story of the 1928 “Tommy Gun”. The 1928 replica is made to hype up the unique history of the firearm (one involving gangsters and violin cases), as well as utilizing a suppressor that is mated perfectly to the gun. It has deep roots in Mafia and crime syndicates, but also in the law enforcement circles that investigated them. The accessorizing of the AR platform and styling makes this easy to customize, and the low weight means you won’t get tired carrying it (it’s under 6 lbs.).
It’s interesting to note that one of the perennial favorites is one of the oldest production models of the .45 Carbine, the infamous Thompson “Sub Machine Gun” though, today’s most popular variant are semi-auto versions of the beloved 1927 or 1928 models. It is, however, not a concept that is appropriate at the "regiment" or lower level, to include the individual soldier and his weapon. It has deep roots in Mafia and crime syndicates, but also in the law enforcement circles that investigated them. Press J to jump to the feed. Available for less than $20 apiece, the M1 Carbine was extremely popular among hunters and shooters in the United States. For the generation that grew up in first person shooter video games or have a penchant for the ultra-tactical options, the Alpine White color scheme allows a bit more of the customizability or one-off feeling to the platform. It takes at least two people to deal with the wounded person. The KRISS is already unique. End Human Trafficking. The M1 Carbine was praised by Soldiers for being lightweight and easy to carry, especially by support troops and guerrilla fighters who only saw occasional fighting. People pretty close to you. The Big Game Hunting Blog is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com, Amazon.co.uk, Amazon.ca and other Amazon stores worldwide. Been there, done that. For the money you cannot find a better .45 carbine, as this is a carbine that fits all the specific criteria of what any .45 carbine enthusiast would be after. ...but it is not a myth. Another version of the M1 Carbine (the M3), was fitted with a primitive infrared scope and an active infrared light. The fact that it includes a suppressor makes it a bit more difficult to obtain (you need a tax stamp and an additional waiting period), but it makes it a special addition to your collection. While the .30 Carbine cartridge is legal to use on deer in many states (like Georgia, Texas, and Washington), it is illegal to use in other states.
Why did they develop a new cartridge, .30 cal.
I learned to shoot at the age of 6 (1961) and was picking the eyes out of starlings with a Daisy “Western Field” lever-action from the time I was out of diapers. Those who like the simplicity of the Thompson 1924 design. For deer I would not use the .30 carbine. Even to the point of being hard to track down. If you severly wound them you usually put 3 people out of the action for some period of time.. Reproduction of any portion of this website only at the permission of GunandShooter. the .30/30 is significantly more powerful than the .30 carbine.... neither the .30 carbine or the .45 acp are deer rounds, unless you were starving and had no other weapon.
This is a true conversation piece. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. The results are: . I was not complaining about the weapon, just wondering why they went with a completely new round. The largest military subreddit on reddit. In fact, Cirillo called the M1 Carbine one of his favorite duty weapons in his legendary book Tales of the Stakeout Squad. As always, you must be aware of what is behind your target when using it because it is absolutely possible for a round to penetrate one or two walls with enough energy remaining to injure or kill someone unintentionally. The 30 carbine was actually created in order to more or less replace the 1911A1 pistol. At least that’s what Hornady’s ballistic charts shows for most average bullet weights. This was the first weapon issued to American Soldiers with true night vision capability. The well-appointed outer shell offers a ton of placement points in the form of rails, for accessory attachment.
It’s not as good as the other variants from a holistic performance perspective, and it is more of a rifle than a carine, but it is serviceable. I have shot the M1 for many years as well as the .357 S&W Magnum (in a lever-action rifle) as well as a number of other handguns and full-power rifle cartridges. Not only is it illegal to use for hunting in most states, but FMJ ammunition does not perform nearly as well as hollow point or soft point ammunition. It goes without saying that the accuracy will be enhanced in a multi-shot scenario; but it is also quite accurate on a per shot basis already. There are very few handgun cartridges that can duplicate this performance. He’d taught me some about the 30 carbine and back then he had one. I used the deer instead of say a some kind of coyote..... now the question is which is the better round at 100yds using only these rifles. Now, the field is a robust offering of different guns that allows you to go super traditional, or ultra-modern and both ends of the spectrum contains variants that are reliable, good looking, fun to use and offer the benefits that the .45 carbine has historically offered.
However, the .30 Carbine cartridge was deemed acceptable by the military because it was not intended to be used by Soldiers involved in heavy fighting as their primary weapon.